At Maddy’s Sweet Shop we continue to do things the old fashion way. Our delightful products are crafted in our artisanal bakery with time honored recipes and the finest ingredients. Our award-winning Lil’ Maddies are a delectable shortbread cookie with a sweet candy crunch, covered on our unique powered sugar coating. Just one taste and you’ll see why we guarantee every batch. Be sure to try all Maddies Sweet Shop creations.
Despite claiming they use the “finest ingredients,” their products include enriched flour, hydrogenated oils, and a host of additives, which are cheap and carcinogenic.
SidGrand Portage, MN
I am a cookie expert, I’ve tried them all. This is the best ever, you can eat a handfull and you dont feel full or feel like you have sinned. I’ve tried the Rasberry and the Butterscotch and they are so good you would slap your Grandma if she tried to take them away from you.
Yes I would recomend you buy them.
This is the best lemon cookie that I have ever tasted. I bought a box at a Ross store and then never saw the product again. I went on to Amazon and bought a case three weeks ago. Between my friends and I they are gone.
I am going to buy another case.
Needed a Mother’s Day gift for some family and friends and found this product and based on the reviews purchased it. Everyone loved the taste of the cookies and wanted to know where I purchased them. Great product at an excellent price. Will order more.
Excellent cookies, but the packages were all beyond the Best Sold By date… Since I wanted to give some as gifts, t was unable to do so. Very disappointing.
We have not been disappointed with any flavor or these cookies. They are the very best! Raspberry is my favorite:)
The case arrived with the pieces mostly broken and the confectioner’s sugar “dusting” all moist, gummy and barely coating the cookies (most of the coating had fallen off). They looked gross, so they ended up NOT being served to guests as a light dessert. Some tasted stale even though they were (barely) in date. The lemon flavor is quite unnatural and the pieces of hard lemon candy baked into these “shortbreads” contributed to this very unnatural flavor. Not a plesant experience and I actually ended up tossing them after tasting the first few boxes. The fact that the shortbreads were broken–very few were whole cookies–added to the disappointment of this purchase. I can’t recommend them for these reasons and won’t purchase again.
Love this product. How can these be 1 pt on weight watchers for 3-4 cookies? My plain shortbread list the following ingredients- wheat flour, butter, sugar, salt. I read the review claiming for this to have all sorts of additives. What kind were they eating? Is it flavored?
ChristopherPennington Gap, VA
Great flavor and plenty of it! It’s like eating chocolates: They are so rich in lime flavor you can only eat 2 or 3 at a time. The bite size morsels are perfect, lots of flavor and great cookie tastes blended together well. We will be buying more.
The Key Lime Shortbread Cookies are divine, absolutely delicious and addicting, perfect texture, perfect keylime flavors that cool your lips and the taste of real butter make them gourmet unlike any commercial brands and definitely set them above even some of the mirobakery shops in town. If you like shortbread, you have got to give these a try, start with a package of 6 and You Will Not Regret it!
I can hardly put these down once I open a package. Bought these originallyt at a discount place (only pkg. they had), but after I finished that pkg. I went hunting for the maker, and then ordered more. Just ordered another batch the other day. Soft, with crunchy little chips in them. Really good.
These cookies are totally addicting!! Don’t dare order them too often. Originally, we were able to buy them at Costco. So glad to find them through Amazon.
I absolutely love these shortbread cookies. Unfortunately my store is out of them and doesn’t know if they’ll get them back in stock. They are plain shortbread…not flavored. I would order the butterscotch if I knew the nutrition count was the same. Could someone give me the nutrition count on the flavored ones?
The plain ones are: 76 cal, 2.5 fat, 5 carbs, less than 1 protein, 0 fiber. Serving size 3 to 4 cookies.
On weight watchers these are only 1 point a serving.
Thank You, Eileen
Maddy’s Key Lime Cookies are like the ones your grandma used to make, when everyone used real butter and really staked their reputation on the cookies they could bring to a gathering. To taste one of these melt-in-your-mouth cookies is to travel back in time. If you want to give your family a really great cookie without baking it yourself, this is the one!
BuenaKing Of Prussia, PA
If you’re looking for something to serve at your next afternoon tea, you’ve just found it! These cookies are premium key-lime pie in finger-food form. The texture is light and slightly crunchy, with a moderately sweet and somewhat tart key-lime flavor. They’re truly sinful and addictive. For this reason, buy these only if you intend to share, lest you’ll find yourself devouring the entire box in one place.
Very delicious cookies, both sweet and crunchy. I got these for Christmas gifts to go along with tea. I think the receivers will really enjoy these.
The flavor is more uniform than others, the confectioner sugar perhaps adheres better.
Light and flavorful. You will not be disappointed.
Buying in quantity enables simple gift-giving. The package is very nice and makes a good presentation.
LydiaMount Vernon, IL
I’ve purchased the lemon, raspberry and shortbread cookies and liked them all. What I like the most about the brand of cookies is that they are not too sweet–perfect for my taste.
I love all foods flavored with lime, and these are by far the best key lime cookies I’ve come across. I am addicted!